Type 1 Diabetes: New Studies on Vegan and Moderate-Carbohydrate Diets for Type 1 Diabetes

Michael Howerton

How many carbohydrates should you eat for ideal health with type 1 diabetes? It’s a question that evades an easy answer. With diabetes nutrition, as with most things, one size doesn’t fit all, according to two new studies.

At the “Are We What We Eat?” symposium at the EASD 2023 conference in Hamburg, Germany, two nutrition researchers presented new data that attempted to, if not answer the question of what the ideal diet should be for those with type 1 diabetes, at least suggest ways to expand the conversation to make it more inclusive.


Dr. Hana Kahleova, director of clinical research at the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine in Washington D.C., presented findings of a study of a plant-based diet versus a standard portion-controlled diet for those with type 1 diabetes. Since insulin dependence is linked to a decreased life span, she said her aim was to find a way to lower the amount of insulin needed for people with type 1 diabetes through nutrition.


Kahleova cited the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT) that documented over 30 years that higher insulin doses in people with type 1 diabetes were associated with a higher body mass index, higher pulse rate, and impaired blood lipids. The consequences have been devastating, she noted, as each increase of 0.1 units/kg/day of insulin dose was associated with a 6% increase in cardiovascular disease.


“Is there anything we can do to address this with nutrition?” Kahleova asked. “Can we actually lower the insulin dose with nutrition?”

The current recommendations for type 1 diabetes are portion control, carbohydrate counting, and minimizing the consumption of processed foods and sugar-sweetened beverages, with the bolus insulin dose calculated based on the carbohydrate content of the meal. Kahleova said thousands of patients reported that different meals with similar carb levels affected them differently, leading to a great deal of confusion and frustration.


“We know that all carbohydrates are not created equal,” she said. “There’s also a lot of variability in terms of fat and protein content and fiber content. The fiber content of the meals seems to be one of the most crucial aspects for people with type 1 diabetes.”

The average American consumes 16 grams of fiber a day, only half the recommended daily amount. The average in Europe is a bit higher with about 20 grams a day, but still not close to enough. Another study has shown that 30-35 grams of fiber a day was associated with a reduction in all-cause mortality by about 15% compared with low-fiber intake.


Fiber in diabetes has a much more important role to people than for the general population

“Fiber in diabetes has a much more important role to people than for the general population,” Kahleova said, adding that for those with diabetes, both type 1 and type 2, the all-cause mortality from fiber deficiency might be as much as 45%, and 39% for cardiovascular disease.


“We know that a plant-based diet has been shown to be beneficial in type 2 diabetes, improving insulin sensitivity as well as improving beta cell function in overweight people with no diabetes,” she said, adding she was curious if the same benefits were possible for those with type 1.


Kahleova said this small study, consisting of 58 people with type 1 diabetes, was the first plant-based diet trial looking at insulin resistance for people with type 1 diabetes, adding that more work now needs to be done to follow up on the encouraging results.

The study found:


  • Energy intake did not change significantly in either group from the start to the end of the trial period. In the vegan group, the carbohydrate intake increased from about 200 g to 300 g a day, while the fat content went down to keep the calories consistent. In the portion-controlled group, the macronutrient ratio stayed steady.
  • Total daily insulin dose did not change in the portion-control group, but it did decrease significantly, by 12.1 units a day, or a 28% drop, in the vegan group.
  • Insulin sensitivity did not change significantly in the portion-control group, but it increased in the vegan group by 144%.
  • A1C deceased in both groups. It decreased by 0.6% in the portion-control group and by 0.8% in the vegan group.
  • Body weight didn’t change not change in the portion-control group, but it did decrease by 11.5 pounds on the vegan diet.
  • Total cholesterol dropped significantly on both diets, but it decreased more on the vegan diet. LDL cholesterol levels were reduced only on the vegan diet.
  • Kidney function improved on the vegan diet over the portion-control diet.


“This is a novel approach for people with type 1 diabetes,” she told diaTribe about the study. “At first, it may seem intimidating to eat so many carbohydrates, but the most important aspect is that when people want to try this diet, they need to keep the fat content low. You need to pick which will be your main fuel.”


Sofia Sterner Isaksson, of the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, presented a different study looking at varying carbohydrate ratios in diets for type 1 diabetes to evaluate the effects of carbohydrate intake on glucose control. Her team compared a moderate-level carbohydrate diet (in which 30% of the day’s energy came from carbohydrates) with a traditional diet (in which half of the day’s calories came from carbohydrates).


The small study, looking at 50 people with type 1 diabetes, found that those on the moderate carbohydrate diet had better glucose control. The group on the moderate carbohydrate diet also had a better average time in range, by 5%, and less time above range, by 6.4%. Also notable, she said, was a reported higher treatment satisfaction rate for the moderate group. There was no increased risk for hypoglycemia, dyslipidemia, ketoacidosis or elevated blood pressure between the two diet groups.


“These results indicate that a moderate carbohydrate diet can be an effective and safe diet option for some people with type 1 diabetes,” Sterner Isaksson said. “Both diets were individualized by a dietitian and were healthy, and this was important so as not to negatively impact other health markers like weight, blood pressure or lipids.”


Reflecting on the data presented earlier by Kahleova, Sterner Isaksson told diaTribe after the panel discussion that it was clear that there was more than one way for people with type 1 diabetes to eat in ways that supported their health and diets should be individualized.

“It’s important to have different types of diets that fit with different individuals,” she said. “Lowering the amount of carbohydrates could fit for some people, but a plant-based diet with higher carbohydrate content with a lot of fibers could work better for others. That is why it’s so nice to see new studies investigating diets in type 1 diabetes.“


Credits

Author: Michael Howerton

Source: https://diatribe.org/type-1-diabetes-new-studies-vegan-and-moderate-carbohydrate-diets-type-1-diabetes

Healthy Bites

April 15, 2025
With so many things happening in the diabetes tech world, it can be hard to keep up. Stay up to date here with the latest diabetes tech news and alerts.
April 10, 2025
Type 2 diabetes, a condition marked by chronically high blood sugar levels, is a leading driver of metabolic disease in America. While conventional medical advice recommends taking medications to control blood sugar levels, this is only a temporary measure at best.  Diabetes is compounded by several factors, and recent research notes that nutritional deficiencies is a commonly overlooked aspect, and that when these deficiencies are addressed, managing and controlling this disease becomes easier.
March 24, 2025
Telemedicine can make diabetes care less expensive and easier to access, but it may not always be a suitable replacement for an in-person visit. Learn what happens during a telehealth visit and see if you could benefit from using telemedicine for your diabetes care. The pandemic upended a lot about life as we knew it. Notably, it was responsible for a 63-fold increase in telehealth visits . For people managing diabetes, however, having a doctor visit over video brings up a host of questions and potential issues. How can a doctor properly check my eyes and feet through a computer screen? Will telehealth replace in-person discussions about my blood sugar? Will I get the same level of care through a computer? According to a 2022 article in American Family Physician , telehealth is promising for diabetes treatment and has been shown to help improve glucose management. In a separate analysis of glucose data from people with type 2 diabetes, people who received remote monitoring of their glucose levels saw significant improvements in A1C over a period of three months. That being said, no study or physician is implying that telehealth fully replaces in-person medical care for diabetes. Here’s what to consider and who might be the best candidates for telediabetes care. What happens during a diabetes telehealth visit? Telediabetes care involves two types of interactions. One is a video meeting with a physician or care team to discuss challenges and potential solutions. During this type of visit, the healthcare provider can see some physical signs or changes, such as rashes or wounds. The second type of interaction is virtual monitoring of glucose levels through a monitoring device that sends data to the care provider. The provider might also follow up with a video call to discuss the data. “Many of the things that are important for diabetes care – blood glucose data review, medication review, insulin teaching – can all happen over video,” said Dr. Varsha Vimalananda, an endocrinologist and associate professor of medicine at Boston University. “CGM data can be uploaded and reviewed remotely, which is also very helpful.” Different providers use different video platforms for telehealth appointments, but most will look and function much like a Zoom call. The benefits of telehealth in diabetes care Not all elements of diabetes care are best suited for telehealth, but many lend themselves naturally to the conversation and convenience that an electronic visit facilitates. For type 2 diabetes in particular, telehealth has been shown to be more effective than in-person care at helping people manage their condition. One reason for the improved outcomes is simply better access to care. Dr. Keta Pandit, an endocrinologist at Texas Diabetes & Endocrinology in Austin, Texas, says continuous glucose monitoring (CGM), along with telehealth options, have changed the landscape of diabetes care. “One of the benefits of being able to offer telemedicine to our patient population is that it has increased the access to care, especially with any ongoing illnesses, hospitalizations, COVID, post-COVID, or any other situations when patients notice their glucose levels are going out of their standard range. Patients often contact us for these types of situations, and we can quickly get them seen via telemedicine to make adjustments to their diabetes medications,” she says. “While this was still an option prior to telemedicine days, the opportunity to see their provider on short notice, not having to worry about transportation, and not having to put in advance notice to take time off of work to travel to the doctor’s office, are some of the ways access to care has increased.” Pandit says this is particularly true for older patients who require frequent visits and women who are pregnant, as well as those who need to optimize their glucose levels before and after surgery. Jasmine Meidas, 51, of Cleveland, Ohio, is one such patient. She was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes 15 years ago. “During the COVID-19 pandemic, I was much more comfortable with telehealth than going into my endocrinologist’s office, which is in a hospital. I still am,” she says. Meidas has a one-hour telehealth visit every three months. “They can order blood work to be taken locally, [and] we review [the results] together. We also review food choices, lifestyle challenges, stressors, and more. We set action steps and goals for the next 90 days,” she says. Meidas periodically sees her endocrinologist in person as well. At Vimalananda’s clinic in Boston, specific groups are making great strides with telehealth options. “Veterans, mostly,” she says. “I have a few [Veteran patients] who have severe [post-traumatic stress disorder]. Driving out to the clinic, dealing with traffic, and navigating the hospital are all things that cause a lot of distress. It’s been a game-changer for them to be able to have the visit from home.” When is telehealth not the best option? “If you have diabetes, please remove your socks and shoes.” This type of sign is frequently displayed in doctors’ offices. How would a foot exam work in telehealth? This is a real concern for people with diabetes, as up to 15% of patients will have a foot ulcer in their lifetime. Pandit and other experts acknowledge the limitations telehealth can have. “The medical team [must depend] on the patient [to provide] data and limited access to other parameters that are needed, including blood pressure measurements or foot examinations. When visits are conducted via telemedicine…care is not as comprehensive,” says Pandit. “There are times when the telemedicine model may pose risks. The limitation is clearly noted in visits with patients who are not technologically savvy, may have hearing issues, or [have] poor [internet] connection at the time of the visit.” Telehealth can also give health care providers a direct view into the home environment, which may result in a patient’s hesitancy to share openly — with family members potentially nearby — and impede the building of relationships and rapport. For these reasons, Pandit recommends that at least every other visit be conducted in person. 
A logo for diabetic supplies inc. and eddy care
March 24, 2025
We are delighted to announce a groundbreaking partnership between Diabetic Supplies Inc. and eddii-Care , the virtual endocrine care clinic hosted by eddii—the leading diabetes management platform.
March 11, 2025
These protein- and fiber-packed spinach, ricotta, and mozzarella egg muffins are a filling yet healthy weekday breakfast option.
March 4, 2025
Key takeaways The FDA has issued a warning to users of continuous glucose monitors after reports of missed urgent blood sugar alarms on smartphones. Free apps can act as a backup for CGM alerts on your phone. A secondary alert system, like a CGM receiver or the SugarPixel standalone display, can ensure critical alerts are noticed. The FDA recently issued a safety notice after receiving reports from CGM users who missed critical low and high blood sugar alerts on their smartphones. Some of the causes for the missed alerts included: changes to phone settings, operating system upgrades, and using Bluetooth accessories. The safety warning coincided with my own experience. Following an update to my smartphone, I missed two critical low blood sugar alerts during the night. After missing those notices, I realized that I could back up my CGM alarms the same way I back up photos on my phone or laptop's hard drive. I then went about researching and testing other backup options, including these apps and devices I now use to make sure alarms are heard consistently, especially at night.
February 12, 2025
Marcia Kadanoff, who lives with type 2 diabetes, shares her top five tips for enjoying a Valentine’s Day meal out. Pink and red hearts everywhere, overpriced dinners, wondering if you’ll have a date (or if you got your partner an appropriate gift) – ah, the joys of Valentine’s Day. I’m stressed just thinking about it. As a person with diabetes, my stress may be a bit different than general Valentine’s Day anxiety. By this point, my spouse knows enough not to get me chocolates, my biggest landmine food. But the hard thing for Valentine's Day or any other romantic occasion is getting a reservation at the right kind of restaurant and – as always when living with diabetes – planning out my meal. Special occasion meals take special skills to navigate. The good news is that there are definitely strategies that can help make a romantic dinner somewhere special enjoyable without diabetes taking center stage. Where I live – the San Francisco Bay Area – many restaurants have Valentine’s Day dinner specials that consist of three to five courses. There’s nothing wrong with eating a multi-course meal, but it does make diabetes management more difficult. From bread to creamy soups and crouton-laden salads to heavy entrées to a dessert that’s potentially cake-filled, multi-course meals can quickly add up to a large amount of carbohydrates, which is a major driver of high blood sugars. The reality is that even if I choose the “healthier” set menu for a celebratory multi-course meal, I still make a point to think about what each portion is bringing (quite literally) to the table. Here are my best tips for navigating a Valentine's Day dinner out.
February 5, 2025
Figuring out when and how to exercise can be one of the most difficult parts of living with diabetes. Hear from experts who discuss the benefits and share strategies for safely exercising. Having diabetes doesn’t mean you have to let go of the things you love doing, which may include playing sports. Exercise is an essential part of diabetes management, leading to improved weight management, reduction in cardiovascular disease risk factors, and great mental health benefits. Experts like Dr. Lori Laffel, chief of the pediatric, adolescent and young adult section at Joslin Diabetes Center, discussed the benefits and strategies for safely exercising with diabetes. Laffel pointed to the ADA’s Standards of Care, which recommend adults get 150-300 minutes per week of moderate-to-vigorous exercise and youth get 420 minutes per week of moderate-to-vigorous exercise. But even with all of the evidence pointing to its benefits, managing exercise can be one of the most difficult parts of living with diabetes. There are multiple challenges to consider, such as abnormal insulin delivery and glucagon physiology, how stress hormones affect blood glucose, hydration, and more. The good news is that you can still stay active with diabetes and engage in the sports you love. Famous athletes who have diabetes include five-time Olympic gold medalist Gary Wayne Hall Jr., recent Super Bowl champion Noah Gray, and the Women’s National Basketball Association’s 2022 third overall pick Lauren Cox. Exercising just might mean a little more planning on your part. This includes paying special attention to the type of physical activity you’re doing, carb intake, and your insulin regimen, said Laffel. How does exercise impact blood sugar? It’s still difficult to know the degree to which exercise affects your blood glucose levels. According to Michael Riddell, professor of kinesiology and health sciences at York University, an optimal glycemic range is “unclear and very individualized for the athlete with diabetes.” Factors that influence one’s glucose response to exercise include the type of activity, time of day, whether you’ve recently taken insulin, what food was recently consumed, stress, sleep, and more. Athletes who compete may want to consider how their levels vary between training days versus competitions. While it might not always be doable in practice, Riddell recommends a time in range of 70% during training and 75% on competition days – while paying special attention to minimizing hypoglycemia to less than 1%. For competitive athletes, other important things to manage include sleep, meals, basal/bolus insulin, hydration, and workout schedules. The type, duration, and intensity of exercise are main factors that influence glucose response. Different forms of physical activity cause different glycemic trends that ultimately affect how you respond to diabetes management. For example, endurance activities (like walking, jogging, and cycling) tend to reduce glucose levels, whereas high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and resistance training tend to vary more so. Laffel said that if you are engaging in intense exercise, know it can cause hyperglycemia and may increase your insulin needs during recovery time. The amount of carbs you should eat to maintain your desired glucose levels will depend on the intensity of your exercise. Lower-intensity exercise typically means more carbs and less insulin needed and vice versa for higher-intensity exercise, explained Riddell. For context, about 50% of recreational athletes with type 1 diabetes prefer training and sometimes competing with a moderately low (100-200 grams per day), low (40-99 grams per day), or very low (<40 grams per day) carb diet. Helpful guidelines and tech for exercise Activity monitors and devices can significantly help with diabetes management while exercising. Connected pens and insulin pumps provide timely dosage; continuous glucose monitors (CGM) let you follow trends to guide your insulin dosing and carb intake; and automated insulin delivery (AID) can protect you from hypoglycemia and possible hyperglycemia. Laffel provided a few basic guidelines if you’re engaging in aerobic exercise for more than 40 minutes. If you’re on multiple daily injections (MDI) or an open-loop pump, consider the following insulin adjustments: For those on MDI, start with a 20% reduction in basal insulin dose. For people on insulin pump therapy, reduce basal rate by about 50% (as a starting point) 1-2 hours before, during, and about one hour after exercise. Reduce bolus insulin by 50% for meals or snacks two hours before and up to two hours after exercise. At bedtime (or 7-11 hours following afternoon exercise) reduce your basal rate by 20% for up to six hours. If you are engaging in unplanned aerobic exercise, eat a few extra carbs. Use a CGM or monitor to check glucose before, during, and after physical activity. According to Laffel, an overlooked but important part of exercising with diabetes is the cool-down period, which can be any sort of exercise that you consider easy, such as walking or a slow jog. Cooling down can reduce your risk of hyperglycemia after vigorous exercise. You should cool down for about 20 minutes. If your glucose levels remain high, you can consider conservative insulin correction (greater than 220 mg/dL). Ultimately, there are many ways you can tailor diabetes management to work for your exercise plan. You should discuss your exercise regime with your doctor, as everyone’s needs are individualized and dependent on their lifestyle.
February 5, 2025
Game day is fast approaching. Here are six diabetes-friendly healthy snack recipes that are all sure to be instant crowd-pleasers. Are you ready for the big game? Whether you're a raving football enthusiast, solely a fan of the commercials, or just around for the food and comradery, it's impossible to deny that the Super Bowl is a big deal. It's important to make sure you'll stay healthy while helping yourself to a few delicious bites. “Traditional Super Bowl snack foods are less than ideal, even if you aren't living with diabetes,” says Heather Hanks, a certified nutritionist and medical adviser at Medical Solutions BCN. Hanks acknowledges that it's always a challenge to eat healthy on Super Bowl Sunday. “The key here is to find snacks that contain no refined sugars and fewer carbs, a good source of protein, healthy fats, and fiber to keep you full and stabilize blood sugar levels.” Diabetes-friendly snacks for game day Bearing these pointers in mind, we have six low-carb finger food options, from cheese dips to buffalo-style cauliflower bites. These healthy snack options will have you partaking in the party without feeling too full or weighed down. 
January 28, 2025
Story at-a-glance Consuming dark chocolate is linked to a 21% reduction in the risk of developing Type 2 diabetes, while milk chocolate does not offer the same benefit and is associated with weight gain
More Posts